There’s been a fascinating and at times uncomfortable conversation happening around the question: if a woman encountered a man or a bear alone in the bush, which would she choose?
As someone who spends a great deal of my time alone in the bush, hiking, backpacking, paddling and travelling through places where the only company may be the wind, the trees, and the occasional wild creature, I find the question particularly interesting.
I understand why it has struck such a nerve. For many women, it speaks to something deeper than a hypothetical encounter. It speaks to really terrible experiences that produce fear, vulnerability, distrust. It’s the quiet calculations women have to make simply moving through the world.
But as someone who has spent so much time finding my way through wild places, I also find myself thinking about the men I have encountered along the way.
Some of the most beautiful moments of my travels have involved men I had never met before. Strangers who offered help without expectation, kindness without agenda, a steady hand when I needed one, or simply a conversation beside a trail that reminded me how generous and connected people can be. Men who looked out for me without ever making me feel small. Men whose goodness was as unexpected and memorable as anything I found in the landscape itself.
This brings me to Barry.
This summer, Casey, Mandee and I found ourselves camping at a ranch in Kananaskis, Alberta, on the precipice of a much bigger adventure, the Wapta Icefield.
Calling it “camping” was perhaps generous. We were really roughing it: tucked away in the middle of a field, no running water, few creature comforts, and the kind of wide-open wilderness that makes you feel very small in the best possible way. It was PERFECT.
Casey and I have been adventure friends for a long time, so we already had our own rhythm. We have the kind of friendship forged through questionable decisions, big mountains, long days and probably more than a few moments of asking ourselves, What exactly have we gotten ourselves into?
Mandee, however, was new to the equation. We had only just met, but somehow she fit into our little adventure ecosystem beautifully. There was an ease to it almost immediately, as though she had been part of the gang much longer than she actually had.
That day, the three of us went horseback riding around the ranch, soaking in the landscape and getting to know one another. By later afternoon, we had settled into that lovely, loose kind of camaraderie that comes after a day outside. Hiking boots kicked off, drinks in hand, stories beginning to get better with every sip.
We were sitting there, enjoying ourselves, when a man came riding up on an e-bike.
He peeled in and with a huge smile, asked us, quite casually, “Who has the British Columbia licence plates?”
That was our first introduction to Barry.
At the time, none of us knew that this slightly random encounter in a field in Kananaskis was about to become one of those small travel moments that sticks with you, not because anything extraordinary happened in the conventional sense, but because of the kind of person you happened to meet.
Maybe that’s exactly why Barry belongs in this conversation about bears.
At first, we were a little reluctant. There’s something about having a complete stranger roll up into your little corner of the wilderness that makes you instinctively pause and cause you to be cautious. We had our own rhythm going, and the interruption felt a little unexpected.
But it didn’t take long for that feeling to disappear. Very quickly, it became clear that Barry fit our vibe almost perfectly.
Barry is in his 60s and lives in northern Saskatchewan. He is, in every sense of the word, an outdoorsman. He bikes, hikes, fishes, explores and clearly has the same restless curiosity about the natural world that had brought the three of us to that field in Kananaskis.
Before long, we were swapping stories as though we had known each other far longer than an afternoon. One story led to another, and somewhere along the way the lines between stranger and friend began to blur.
Barry loves music. He loves life. He has that wonderful kind of enthusiasm that makes you want to keep listening, keep asking questions, keep the conversation going just a little longer. So, naturally, Barry joined us around the campfire.
There were drinks, music, laughter and those unexpectedly beautiful conversations that seem to happen more easily outdoors, when the sky is enormous, the mountains watch from the distance, the fire is crackling and nobody is in any particular hurry to go anywhere.
A complete stranger had arrived on an e-bike, and somehow, by the end of the evening, it felt like Barry had always been part of the group. I remember thinking: this is the part of the “man or bear” conversation that gets lost.
When bedtime came we discussed plans for the following day. Casey, Mandee and I were hiking Yamnuska and Barry had plans for his own biking/hiking adventure. We decided that we would meet up the following evening for more conversation and maybe a few more drinks.
After another wonderfully adventurous day, Barry showed up at our campsite again. This time, we had a few more adventure companions with us, and we had actually planned a hilarious little prank for Barry. But somewhere between seeing him roll up and the sheer excitement of having him back, the prank completely fell apart. We were far too happy to see him to pull it off.
Once again, Barry slipped effortlessly into our little circle. He had this beautiful way of drawing people into a conversation, weaving our new adventure friends into the stories and laughter even though most of us had never met before. It was one of those rare qualities that makes someone feel instantly familiar, a person who doesn’t just tell stories, but creates space for everyone else to become part of them. So, once again, the evening unfolded around a campfire with laughter, drinks and stories stretching into the night.
But as the evening wore on, I felt that familiar heaviness begin to settle somewhere around my heart because I knew that tomorrow we would part ways.
That is one of the bittersweet truths of travelling. You meet people in the most unexpected places, sometimes under the most unlikely circumstances, and for a brief moment your lives overlap. You share a campfire, a trail, a meal, a few stories and somehow, in a remarkably short time, they become part of your story, and then you leave.
There are hugs. Numbers exchanged. Promises to keep in touch and then Barry climbed onto his e-bike and disappeared into the darkness, heading back toward his trailer.
I watched his little light fade into the night and thought about how strange and wonderful travel can be. How a complete stranger can arrive out of nowhere and, for a couple of days, become part of your world and how lucky we are when those strangers turn out to be people like Barry.
Nature has taught me that the world is not easily divided into safe and dangerous, good and bad, friend and foe. It is more complicated, more mysterious than that. And perhaps people are too.
I don’t want to dismiss the experiences that have led women to choose the bear. Those stories deserve to be heard. But I also don’t want the conversation to leave us with the impression that men, as a whole, are something to fear.
My travels have introduced me to some extraordinary men, quietly decent, generous, funny, courageous and deeply kind. In a world that can sometimes feel determined to divide us into opposing camps, I think those encounters are worth remembering too.
So perhaps this is less about choosing between a man and a bear, and more about the stories we carry with us into the wild and what those stories have taught us about one another.
For me, one of those stories will always be Barry: a stranger who arrived on an e-bike, became part of our little adventure for a couple of unforgettable days, and left us feeling grateful that we had crossed paths. Because sometimes the wilderness doesn’t just introduce us to ourselves, it introduces us to wonderful people we never would have otherwise known. And sometimes, if we’re lucky, those people are named Barry.













































